Why didn't OUR councils fight?

In 2016 on the eve of amalgamation two motions were tabled. One expressing support for Woollahra Council’s legal challenge to their forced merger. The other seeking to join them.

Save Our Council

The motions were lost.

“The case for mergers never stacked up. That’s why communities across the inner west did not want to merge, and why I voted in favour of joining other inner-city councils by challenging our proposed merger in the courts,” said one independent councillor. That was John Stamolis, who is now running as an Independent in the Balmain ward.

When council mergers rolled out across NSW two stood out more than others.  

Mid Coast (Gloucester, Great Lakes and Greater Taree)

These communities opposed coal seam gas. Their punishment? Appointment of former Nationals MP John Harcourt Turner as their administrator. The Chairman of the Community Consultative Committee for Whitehaven Coal – ouch….

Inner West (Leichhardt, Marrickville, Ashfield)

These communities opposed Westconnex. Their punishment? The appointment of a former director of the NSW Department of Planning as their administrator. That’s the department that approved Westconnex, despite strong resistance from our former councils – nice….

Oh and did I mention that both of these administrator’s advised the NSW Government on how to implement council amalgamations? I think the proposal was called Amalgamation for Dummies.

Inner West Council and Westconex

Check out how neatly the Westconnex route fits within the inner west council boundaries.

The administrator ensured council’s voice was muffled. A few statements, with the adjective 'strongly' inserted, were the best our new 'council' would muster.

But why didn’t we fight the merger? Other councils did.

We wouldn’t have been alone. We could’ve leveraged costs, resources, even legal arguments. The motion was on the table. The community in the gallery yelled in unison “YES!  FIGHT! YES!”

(Extract from Leichhardt Council minutes 22 March 2016 )


“That Council contact Woollahra Council and seek to join their pending court action against forced amalgamations.” (Channells/ Porteous)

These voted in favour. These listened to the community.

FOR: Cr Rochelle Porteous, Cr Craig Channells, Cr Michele McKenzie, Cr John Stamolis

But two parties, often ideologically opposed, did not. Two parties voted in the interests of themselves and against the wishes of the community.

AGAINST: Cr John Jobling, Cr Tony Costantino, Cr Darcy Byrne, Cr Simon Emsley, Cr Linda Kelly, Cr Frank Breen

Liberal and Labour handshake

“Instead of challenging the merger, our Liberal and Labor Councillors teamed up to force the merger upon us,” recalls Stamolis.

A few months before, Labor mayors Darcy Byrne (Leichhardt), Sam Iskandar (Marrickville) and Lucille McKenna (Ashfield) met with Local Government Minister Paul Toole, who gave undertakings he would take the proposed merger to the Boundaries Commission and the councils would receive the $25 million carrot on offer to councils who accept a merger, reported the Inner West Courier on 11 November 2015.

Byrne said the mayors had expressed their disappointment at the process but they had received legal advice that the government could suspend councillors and appoint administrators which meant forced mergers could go ahead, continued the local tabloid.

Afraid they would be dismissed, that night they chose to comply. They voted NO to challenge the merger. 

How could their legal advice have been so different to other councils? 

Their fears came true – karma perhaps. They were sacked, an administrator appointed and we were amalgamated. Oh the injustice. These Liberals can’t be trusted. They would proclaim.

Injustice indeed. Injustice for our community.... 

On 9 September they'll proclaim again -  vote for my party, vote for me, me, me, vote labor. We'll look out for the community. We'll shirt-front those sneaky Liberals.

On 9 September Think Independently. Across the inner west there are independents who truly care for our community. Independents that will always vote with the community.


Showing 5 reactions

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Davie Stevens
    commented 2018-05-03 14:15:13 +1000
    Pretty disappointing to hear. More work needs to be done in our Inner West. We have plenty of great small businesses here such as https://nudesignbathrooms.com/
  • anonymous
    commented 2017-11-07 21:43:35 +1100
    I am impressed by the quality of information on this website. There are a lot of good resources here. I am sure I will visit this place again as soo
  • anonymous
    commented 2017-11-01 17:45:41 +1100
    Truly exceptionally cheerful to say,your post is extremely intriguing to peruse.Quality articles is the fundamental to welcome the customers to pay visit the webpage,that’s what this website is giving
  • John Lozano
    published this page in Blog 2017-07-28 13:23:03 +1000
  • John Lozano
    published this page in Blog 2017-07-28 12:46:43 +1000